Are You Taking the Right Kind of Magnesium?

Magnesium. It seems like everybody is taking it these days. But are you taking the right kind of magnesium? And do you even know what you’re taking it for?

Walk into a pharmacy or health food store and look at the different types of magnesium supplements available. Citrate, glycinate, bisglycinate, malate, oxide, threonate. The list goes on.

One promises better sleep. Another is supposed to help your muscles. Another claims to support your brain. And apparently, some are worth considerably more money than others.

So what the hell is the difference?

I’ve been taking magnesium for quite a while, and I’ve experimented with several forms and different dosages. But the more I look into it, the more questions I have.

And I suspect I’m not alone.

What Does Magnesium Actually Do for Your Body?

Before worrying about which bottle to buy, let’s understand why magnesium matters in the first place.

Magnesium is an essential mineral involved in hundreds of chemical reactions throughout your body.

It helps your muscles and nerves function, supports energy production, contributes to healthy bones, and plays an important role in regulating blood sugar and blood pressure.

It’s also involved in protein synthesis and the normal functioning of your heart.

In other words, this isn’t some trendy supplement somebody invented to sell you another bottle of pills.

Your body genuinely needs magnesium to function.

According to the National Institutes of Health, adult men over 50 generally need about 420 milligrams of magnesium daily, while women over 50 need about 320 milligrams.

Those figures represent total daily intake from food and other sources, not a recommendation to swallow that amount in supplements.

You can read the details in the NIH magnesium fact sheet.

Why Are So Many People Short of Magnesium?

Here’s something I’ve been wondering about for years.

If magnesium is naturally present in food, why does it seem that everybody suddenly needs to supplement it?

Did we lose it from our soil? Did it disappear from our food supply? Or have we simply changed the way we eat?

I suspect our modern eating habits have a great deal to do with it.

Magnesium is found naturally in leafy green vegetables, nuts, seeds, beans, and whole grains.

But look at how many people eat today.

Highly refined foods, sugary snacks, white flour products, processed meals, and all kinds of manufactured crap that has replaced the foods people used to prepare themselves.

Refining grains, for example, removes much of the nutrient-rich bran and germ, taking a substantial amount of magnesium along with it.

So before blaming the soil for everything, maybe we should take a closer look at what’s in our shopping carts.

But What About Depleted Soil?

That question deserves attention too.

Magnesium availability in soil can vary considerably depending on soil composition, acidity, agricultural practices, and other factors.

Researchers have documented magnesium deficiencies affecting crops in certain agricultural regions. Some studies have also examined declining mineral concentrations in particular foods.

But that doesn’t mean every farm has depleted soil or that all modern vegetables are nutritionally worthless.

What it does mean is that the relationship between soil quality, agriculture, and human nutrition deserves more attention.

There’s an interesting research review on magnesium deficiency and sustainable agriculture available through PubMed.

Personally, I think we should be asking more questions about the nutritional quality of the food we’re producing, rather than simply assuming everything is fine because the supermarket shelves are full.

Different Types of Magnesium: What’s the Difference?

Now let’s get to the part that confuses so many people.

Magnesium supplements come in different chemical forms. The magnesium is combined with another substance, and that combination can affect absorption, digestion, and how the product is used.

That doesn’t necessarily mean one form is the best choice for everybody.

Magnesium Glycinate and Bisglycinate

This is the form I’m currently taking.

Magnesium glycinate, often sold as magnesium bisglycinate, combines magnesium with the amino acid glycine.

It’s popular with people looking for a supplement that’s relatively gentle on the digestive system.

It’s also widely promoted for relaxation and sleep.

There is some research exploring magnesium and sleep, but the evidence doesn’t establish that magnesium glycinate is some guaranteed sleeping pill.

I’ve been taking two capsules at night for quite a while.

Do I sleep better because of it?

That’s difficult for me to answer, and I’ll explain why in a minute.

Magnesium Citrate

I’ve used this form too.

Magnesium citrate is one of the better-studied forms when it comes to absorption.

It’s also known for its ability to draw water into the intestines, which is why magnesium citrate preparations are sometimes used to relieve constipation.

That’s useful for some people, but not necessarily what everybody wants from their daily supplement.

I previously took citrate along with bisglycinate, trying to determine whether the combination offered any benefit.

Like most of my supplement experiments, the results weren’t exactly dramatic.

Magnesium Malate

Magnesium malate combines magnesium with malic acid, a substance involved in normal energy metabolism.

You’ll often see it marketed for energy, fatigue, and muscle function.

That sounds attractive, doesn’t it?

But there’s a difference between knowing what malic acid does in the body and proving that magnesium malate supplements produce a meaningful improvement in energy or fatigue.

I wouldn’t automatically pay extra for claims that haven’t been convincingly demonstrated.

Magnesium L-Threonate

This one is often promoted for brain health, memory, and cognitive function.

Some early research has generated interest, but the evidence in humans is still developing.

It’s also frequently more expensive than more conventional forms.

If somebody is charging me considerably more money for a product, I’d like to know whether there’s solid evidence behind the price.

Magnesium Oxide

Magnesium oxide is commonly found in inexpensive supplements.

It contains a relatively high proportion of elemental magnesium by weight, which can make the label look impressive.

But magnesium oxide is generally absorbed less efficiently than certain other forms, including citrate.

That doesn’t make it useless. It has legitimate applications, including some digestive uses.

It simply demonstrates why comparing magnesium supplements by the number on the front of the bottle can be misleading.

Quick Comparison: Which Type of Magnesium Does What?

This chart is a practical summary, not a promise. A check mark means a form is commonly associated with that use or characteristic — not that it is guaranteed to work the same way for everyone.

Type Generally Well Absorbed Gentle on Digestion May Loosen Bowels Often Used For Important Note
Glycinate / Bisglycinate ✓ ✓ — Sleep, relaxation, general supplementation Popular choice, but don’t expect it to act like a sleeping pill.
Citrate ✓ Usually okay, but can bother some people ✓ General supplementation, constipation Often a sensible all-purpose choice, but can loosen stools.
Malate Reasonable, but less comparative evidence ✓ — Energy, muscle complaints Often marketed for energy, but the evidence is not especially strong.
L-Threonate Limited comparative data ✓ — Memory, cognition Interesting, but usually more expensive and still developing in evidence.
Oxide Lower relative absorption Can cause digestive effects ✓ Constipation, antacid use Cheap and common, but not usually my first choice for daily supplementation.

Not All Magnesium Supplements Are Created Equal

This is something that comes up regularly in my own family.

My sisters take vitamins and supplements too, but we don’t always agree about what to buy.

Some of them are perfectly happy to buy whatever happens to be on sale.

I’ve never been particularly comfortable with that approach.

I don’t believe the cheapest bottle on the shelf is automatically the best value.

But I don’t believe the most expensive one is automatically better either.

What I want to know is what I’m actually putting into my body.

Which form of magnesium does it contain? How much elemental magnesium am I getting? What other ingredients are in the capsule? And does the manufacturer have a reputation worth trusting?

In Canada, natural health products generally require a Natural Product Number, or NPN, indicating that Health Canada has authorized the product under specified conditions.

You can check a product using Health Canada’s Licensed Natural Health Products Database.

Independent quality testing can provide another useful piece of information, especially when it verifies ingredient identity, potency, and contaminants.

There’s nothing wrong with finding a good product on sale.

Just don’t confuse a low price with good quality.

How Much Magnesium Is Too Much?

Now here’s where my own experience becomes interesting.

When I first began experimenting with magnesium supplements, I was taking quite a bit.

At one point, I may have been taking more than 800 milligrams a day, depending on how the amounts on the labels were calculated.

I started with several capsules daily, later experimented with a combination of citrate and bisglycinate, and eventually reduced my routine.

Today, I’m down to two bisglycinate capsules at night.

One important thing I’ve learned is that there’s a difference between the amount of a magnesium compound and the amount of actual, or elemental, magnesium it contains.

A bottle advertising 800 milligrams of magnesium bisglycinate doesn’t necessarily provide 800 milligrams of elemental magnesium.

You need to read the label carefully.

For adults, the U.S. National Institutes of Health lists an upper intake level of 350 milligrams per day for magnesium from supplements and medications, rather than magnesium naturally present in food.

Higher supplemental doses can cause digestive problems, and excessive amounts can be especially dangerous when kidney function is impaired.

I don’t remember experiencing the kind of loose stools or digestive problems that people often associate with excessive magnesium.

But the absence of those symptoms doesn’t prove that taking large amounts was a good idea.

Looking back, I wonder whether I was taking more than I needed.

Should You Actually Feel a Magnesium Supplement Working?

I’ve always found this difficult.

I know people who take something and can immediately tell you how it makes them feel.

They feel calmer. They sleep better. They have more energy. They notice some kind of physical change.

That hasn’t been my experience with most supplements.

I’ve had profound changes in the way I experience physical sensations, emotions, and other aspects of my physiology since the health problems I associate with mercury exposure.

Sometimes my reactions to physical sensations seem delayed. And I’ve often found it difficult to determine whether something I’m taking is having any noticeable effect.

For years, I experimented with different supplements, sometimes taking several at once.

Eventually, I realized I couldn’t reliably tell which one was doing what.

That’s one reason I’ve simplified my routine considerably.

But there’s an important distinction here.

Just because you can’t feel a supplement working doesn’t necessarily mean it isn’t doing anything.

Magnesium supports processes that occur whether we’re consciously aware of them or not.

And taking more doesn’t automatically produce a stronger or more noticeable benefit.

I’ve become much more interested in knowing why I’m taking something, what evidence supports it, and whether there’s a sensible reason to continue.

I’ve written about the broader question of nutrition and unexplained symptoms in Could Your Symptoms Be Nutritional?.

What About Muscle Cramps?

Here’s something else I’ve noticed about magnesium.

As I’ve gotten older, I’ve become more aware of muscle cramps, particularly leg cramps. And I’m certainly not alone. My mother and sisters have talked about them too.

One thing I’ve noticed over the years is that when I’m taking magnesium regularly, I generally don’t get many muscle cramps. I wouldn’t say they’ve disappeared completely, but when I do get the occasional cramp, it usually isn’t nearly as severe.

That’s a difference I’ve noticed often enough to get my attention.

Does that mean magnesium is responsible? I can’t prove it. And when I do get a cramp, I sometimes wonder whether I need more magnesium. But that’s something I haven’t really established.

What we do know is that magnesium plays an important role in normal muscle function, and a magnesium deficiency can contribute to muscle contractions and cramps.

Interestingly, that doesn’t mean taking extra magnesium will necessarily prevent cramps. A Cochrane review of magnesium for muscle cramps found that supplements generally didn’t produce meaningful improvements in ordinary muscle cramps among older adults.

So the research isn’t as straightforward as some supplement advertising might have you believe.

Nevertheless, my experience has been positive, and I’ve heard similar observations from my own family. That’s worth mentioning, even if I can’t explain exactly why it happens.

Can You Get Enough Magnesium From Food?

Absolutely, many people can.

And this brings me right back to something I’ve believed for most of my life.

Start with food.

  • Pumpkin seeds: approximately 156 mg per ounce.
  • Chia seeds: approximately 111 mg per ounce.
  • Almonds: approximately 80 mg per ounce.
  • Cooked spinach: approximately 78 mg per half cup.
  • Black beans: approximately 60 mg per half cup.
  • Avocado: approximately 22 mg per half cup.

Those figures are approximate and come from the NIH’s published food-source table.

Notice something?

These are ordinary foods. You don’t need to purchase some exotic superfood shipped halfway around the world.

I’ve always preferred a diet built around real food, mostly plants, with fish and other wholesome foods as part of the mix.

There’s a good reason for that. You’re getting a whole range of nutrients together, rather than trying to reconstruct your nutrition one capsule at a time.

That doesn’t mean supplements have no place.

But I don’t think we should treat them as a substitute for learning how to eat properly.

How Do You Know Which Magnesium Is Right for You?

Here’s how I’d approach the question now, after years of experimenting.

First, figure out why you want to take magnesium in the first place.

Are you concerned about getting enough in your diet? Are you interested in sleep? Do you have digestive issues? Or are you simply buying it because somebody told you everybody needs magnesium?

Those are very different reasons.

Second, look at the form you’re buying. Different magnesium compounds have different characteristics, and the cheapest one isn’t necessarily the most appropriate.

Third, read the actual label. Pay attention to elemental magnesium, the recommended dose, the other ingredients, and the manufacturer’s credentials.

Fourth, don’t assume more is better.

And finally, give some thought to whether you need a supplement at all. Your diet, age, health, medications, and individual circumstances all matter.

This is part of what I mean when I talk about taking responsibility for your own health.

I’ve discussed that broader approach in How to Get Healthy: Where Do You Start?.

My Final Thoughts on Magnesium

After all my experimentation, I’ve reached a fairly simple conclusion.

Magnesium is important. There’s no question about that.

But that doesn’t mean every magnesium supplement is equally useful, or that everybody needs to take the same form or the same amount.

I’m still taking magnesium bisglycinate at night. I’ve tried citrate, experimented with different combinations, and changed my dosage considerably over time.

Do I know with absolute certainty that my current supplement is providing some dramatic benefit?

No. And I’m not going to pretend otherwise.

What I do know is that I want to understand what I’m taking and why.

I don’t want to buy a supplement simply because it’s cheap, because somebody on the internet swears by it, or because the bottle makes some impressive promise.

And I certainly don’t want to spend money on something without knowing what’s actually inside it.

So what’s my answer to the question in the title?

If you’re simply looking for a sensible place to start, here it is:

  • For general daily supplementation, magnesium glycinate or citrate are often the most reasonable starting points.
  • If constipation is part of the problem, citrate may make more sense.
  • If you’re mainly chasing sleep or relaxation, glycinate is a common choice, but don’t expect miracles.
  • If you’re being sold something exotic and expensive, make sure the evidence justifies the price.
  • And before taking large doses, read the label carefully and find out how much elemental magnesium you’re actually getting.

In other words, the right kind of magnesium depends on why you’re taking it, how your body responds to it, and whether the product itself is worth trusting.

That’s the real answer.

Know what you’re taking. Know why you’re taking it. And make sure you’re getting what you paid for.

That’s what taking responsibility for your health is all about.

Insure Your Health Yourself.

Author of Insure Your Health Yourself

Insure Your Health Yourself is about taking a more active role in your own health through prevention, movement, nutrition, self-reliance, and a better way to age — drawing on lived experience, family longevity, and lessons learned the hard way.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.